Recently somebody suggested to me that listening to audiobooks was tantamount to cheating and the only acceptable way to absorb a novel is by reading it on paper. It’s not the first time I’ve heard this argument, neither is it the first time that I’ve hit back with a fistful of counterpoints to show this viewpoint as utter nonsense.
Don’t get me wrong, I love books and you only have to wander around my house to realise how much. I’ve bookshelves in most rooms and they are packed with a combination of novels, non-fictions and reference books. And before you ask, they’re not all written by me. I love the feel of books, their smell and the sensation of turning the page but I wouldn’t say I have a favourite medium through which to absorb stories. For me it is context dependent rather than spawned by illogical snobbery.
Are audiobooks cheating, or still reading?
A book is a book or rather a story is a story. A thriller can be equally gripping whether it is printed, displayed on Kindle (other e-readers are available) or spoken by a narrator. The format is irrelevant. Some people prefer to watch movies on television than in a cinema or to listen to music through headphones rather than live. They’re not judged yet in the literary world some people seem to attach more weight to how the story is delivered rather than the reading experience itself.
Why I switch between print, Kindle and audiobooks
I read physical books, e-books and listen to audiobooks in equal measure. If I want to get through a book quickly, sometimes for work but also for pleasure, I will invariably choose an audiobook as I can use downtime as reading time. If I’m going on holiday I will take my Kindle as I can never judge how many books I will read while away and my baggage allowance rarely accommodates my paranoia that I might run out of reading material. But often I will open a physical book and immerse myself in the old-fashioned way.
There are some authors whose books I only listen to. That’s not because I’m lazy or suffer from a particular eye strain, it’s due to their narrators being so good that they add whole new dimensions to the story and characters through their delivery, rhythm, timing and emotional nuance. Conversely, there are others whose books I love to read electronically or in print because their narrators don’t do it for me but that’s entirely personal choice. Because I opt for one method over another does not mean I’m cheating and I am still a reader.
How audiobooks and e-books make reading accessible
Audio and e-books make literature accessible to a whole range of people especially those with dyslexia, visual impairments, physical disabilities or conditions that make print reading difficult. Audiobooks can be sped up and slowed down by the user. E-readers have adjustable font sizes, different display settings and, on some devices, built-in reading aids.
There’s also affordability. Through streaming sites and e-reader platforms books are so much more available to those on lower incomes. A new hardback from a household name author can cost up to £25 whilst in a digital format a couple of months after publication they can cost 99p or even be free. Libraries offer different formats including audio and e-versions as well as physical books, all for free. You might wonder why an author is promoting cheaper and free ways of accessing books but the important thing is for people to read and for those who can’t get on with print versions providing a range of options so they can still enjoy the written word.
Why audiobook listeners are still readers
A novel’s quality rests in the writing, ideas, character and impact not how the words are presented to the reader. Audiobook listeners still have to follow the story, understand its meaning and imagine its world. Arguably they have to concentrate harder as distractions come easier to listeners. Countless people I’ve spoken to have discovered or re-discovered reading through audio or e-versions. How is that a bad thing?
Although it might appear a solitary pastime, reading unites people and should not divide them.
Literary culture and people’s view of the world benefits when they share their enthusiasm for books and policing the right or wrong method of how they enjoyed them has no more merit than arguing your favourite colour should be everyone’s.
I originally wrote this for my weekly column in The Argus, published on Monday, 26 October 2026. Photo by Yusuf Shamsudeen on Unsplash.